We Loved Once and True (I, II & III) is an optional story mission in Red Dead Redemption 2 given by Mary Linton, as part of Chapter 2.
It's the 16° mission in chronological order of the RDR2 story mode, played with protagonist Arthur Morgan.
While optional for story progression, this is an Optional Honor Mission required for the "Lending a Hand" Trophy/Achievement. It's a time-sensitive and missable mission, so it can only be played at this specific point in the story.
We Loved Once and True (I, II & III) - Mission Details:
After finding Jamie in Cumberland Forest with the Chelonian religious order, Arthur tries to convince him to return to Mary.
Mission Objectives
Gold Medal Objectives (100%)
The following are the Mission Objectives required to obtain the Gold Medal in the mission "We Loved Once and True (I, II & III)":
- Peacefully convince the Chelonians to let you take Jamie
- Return Jamie to Mary within 2 minutes
Note: You must complete all Gold Medal requirements in one single playthrough of the mission.
We Loved Once and True (I, II & III): Mission Info
- Mission Number16
- Story ChapterChapter 2
- Mission TypeOptional (Missable)
- Mission Giver
Mary Linton - Protagonist (Playable)
Arthur Morgan - LocationCumberland Forest (New Hanover)
- RewardsHonor
- NotesOptional Honor Mission, required for the "Lending a Hand" Trophy/Achievement.
- Featuring
Chelonian Master 
Jamie Gillis 
Chelonian Cult
or post as a guest